For a fanbase desperately seeking a spark, this performance felt like a breath of fresh air. The Red Devils’ attacking verve and clinical finishing were a stark contrast to the dreary displays that have often punctuated their season.
Yet, amidst the euphoria, the win also highlighted lingering concerns, both on and off the pitch.
THE GOOD: Amorim’s Attacking Revolution
Ruben Amorim’s arrival appears to have breathed new life into Manchester United’s attack.
Marcus Rashford, reinvigorated under the Portuguese manager, was at the heart of the action, netting his third goal in as many games.
His first-half opener may have benefitted from a deflection off Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite, but his second—a sublime finish after a blistering run—showed the poise and pace that make him so dangerous.
The revelation of the day, however, was Joshua Zirkzee. The Dutchman, who had managed just one goal in 18 previous appearances, looked reborn after finding the net twice.
His first came following a sharp dispossession by Amad Diallo, while his second capped off a commanding display after another assist from the impressive Diallo.
United’s relentless pressing and fluid interplay, epitomised by Diallo’s creativity, were hallmarks of a team rediscovering its attacking identity. This was a side playing with purpose, pace, and precision—qualities often missing in recent months.
THE BAD: Defensive Frailties and Costly Cards
For all their attacking brilliance, United’s defensive setup still showed cracks. Everton, while struggling to capitalise, managed to expose moments of disorganization, especially in transitions.
Such lapses might prove costly against tougher opposition, with Arsenal looming large on the horizon.
Even more concerning were the suspensions to Kobbie Mainoo and Lisandro Martinez, both of whom picked up their fifth yellow cards of the season.
Martinez’s absence, in particular, leaves a gaping hole in Amorim’s backline. The Argentine has been central to United’s defensive structure, and his composure will be sorely missed in the upcoming clash against the Gunners.
THE UGLY: Off-Pitch Protests and Controversy
While the on-pitch display brought smiles, the atmosphere outside Old Trafford was far less celebratory.
Protests against owners Jim Ratcliffe and the Glazer family dominated the pre-match buildup, fueled by the club’s contentious decision to raise ticket prices to £66 per match without concessions for children or pensioners.
The move has sparked outrage among supporters, highlighting the growing disconnect between the club’s hierarchy and its fanbase.
A Promising Start, but Tougher Tests Await
Amorim’s home Premier League debut was a triumph, but the true measure of his Manchester United project lies ahead.
Wednesday’s trip to the Emirates will pit his side against a formidable Arsenal team, and the absences of Martinez and Mainoo will test the depth and resilience of United’s squad.
For now, though, the Portuguese tactician can savour a performance that delivered much-needed optimism.
A ninth-place position and a four-point gap to the top four suggest progress, but consistency remains the key. United fans will hope that Amorim’s attacking blueprint continues to evolve and that this win serves as a foundation for the challenges to come.